Evaluation of Acute and Sub-Chronic Oral Toxicity Study
of Ethanolic Extract of Crataeva nurvala Buch-Ham
Stem Bark on Experimental Wistar Rats
Atanu
Bhattacharjee1*, Shastry Chakrakodi Shashidhara2, Santanu
Saha1
1Department of
Pharmacognosy, NGSM Institute of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Deralakatte,
Mangalore – 574 018, Karnataka, India
2Department of
Pharmacology, NGSM Institute of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Deralakatte,
Mangalore – 574 018, Karnataka, India
ABSTRACT:
Crataeva nurvala Buch-Hum
(Varuna) is a well known traditional Indian medicinal
plant used in the treatment of various ailments in particular urolithiasis. The purpose of the study was to evaluate
acute and sub-chronic oral toxicity of ethanolic
extract of the plant. Acute and
sub-chronic oral toxicity of ethanolic extract of Crataeva nurvala stem
bark were evaluated in female Wistar rats as per
OECD-425 guidelines. A fixed dosage study was adopted for acute toxicity study
where the limit dose is 2000 mg/kg body weight of test animal. Signs of
toxicity were observed every hour for the first 6 h and every day for 7 days.
In the sub-chronic toxicity study the animals were orally administered a single
dose of 175, 550 and 1750 mg/kg body weight for 14 days. Clinical signs of
toxicity, body weight changes, cage side parameters and mortality rate were
monitored after 30 minutes (with special attention for first 4 hours),
periodically for 24 hour of administration of the extract and daily thereafter
for 14 days. Results revealed no mortalities or clinical signs in rats during
the study. The high no observed adverse effects level (NOAEL) value of 2000
mg/kg body weight implies that the drug could be safe. Acute toxicity study
revealed that Crataeva nurvala stem
bark is non-toxic at LD50 more than 2000 mg/kg body weight of
animals.
KEYWORDS: Crataeva nurvala, Acute
toxicity, Sub-chronic toxicity, Stem bark, Wistar rat
INTRODUCTION:
Historically, traditional medicinal plants
have occupied a vital place among rural people of India for the treatment of
various acute and chronic diseases 1.
From last two decades, the utility of medicinal plants have been phenomenally
increased due to their vast chemical biodiversity as World Health Organization
advocated traditional medicines as safer remedies 2. It is a common view across the country that, herbs
are natural, hence are safe 3.
Several reports have demonstrated that natural compounds and herbal products
may cause pharmacokinetic interaction with western drugs used clinically when
they are simultaneously administered. Some time, they produce toxic effects at
higher doses and others might have potentially adverse effects after prolonged
use4. Hence, lack of
standardization, documentation of toxic profile becomes a major concern
regarding safe use of herbal medicines5.
Crataeva nurvala (C. nurvala) Buch-Ham (Family: Capparidaceae) commonly known as Varuna,
is an evergreen tree indigenous to India 6.
It is a medium sized branched deciduous plant distributed throughout the river
banks of southern India and other tropical, sub-tropical countries of the
world, wild or cultivated 7.
It requires dry, hot climate and shady places to grow effectively. Vedic
literatures described its potentiality as blood purifier and to maintain
homeostasis 8. Its bark
is hot, bitter at first and then sweet sharp taste, easy to digest, stomachic,
laxative, anthelmintic, expectorant and anti-pyretic 9. Moreover, pharmacological
study reveals the potentiality of C. nurvala extract and its active principle, particularly lupeol as diuretic, anti-inflammatory, antioxidant, cardio-protective,
hepatoprotective, lithonotriptic, anti-rheumatic, anti-periodic,
contraceptive, anti-protozoal, rubifacient
and vesicant 10. With
this back ground, an attempt has been taken to establish toxic profile for C. nurvala
through acute toxicity study on Wistar rats based on
OECD-425 guideline.
MATERIALS
AND METHODS:
Collection of plant
material:
The stem bark of C. nurvala was collected from the stream sides of Western Ghat, India in September, 2012. The plant was identified
and authenticated by Dr. K.V. Nagalakshamma,
Professor and Head, Department of Biotechnology (UG) of St. Aloysius College,
Mangalore, India and herbarium (voucher specimen no. NGSMIPS/Hb-04/2011) was
preserved in the institutional department
Extraction:
100 gm coarsely powdered raw material of C. nurvala was extracted by cold
maceration with ethanol for 3 days, with frequent shaking for first day and
occasional stirring for the remaining days at room temperature. The process was
repeated once more in order to increase the yield. The extract was concentrated
by rotary flash evaporator at 400C under reduced pressure and stored
in deep freezer at -200C 11.
The yield of ethanolic extract was found to be 17 %
w/w.
Experimental animals:
Healthy young female Wistar rats (nulliparous and non-pregnant) aged between 8-12 week old
and weighing between 120-150 gm obtained from the institutional animal house
were used for the acute toxicity study. The animals were housed in a
cross-ventilated room under standard environmental condition (250C
and 50-70% relative humidity) of 12/12 h light/dark cycle and fed with standard
rat pellet and water ad-libitum 12.
The composition feed are tabulated in table 1. Animals were allowed to
acclimatization for 5 days to the laboratory conditions before the experiment.
The experiment was performed in accordance with the guidelines established by
Institutional Animal Ethical Committee (IAEC).
Table 1:
Composition of Feed
|
Name |
Percentage |
|
Crude
Protein |
20 -
21 % minimum |
|
Ether
Extractive |
04 -
05 % minimum |
|
Crude
Fiber |
04 %
maximum |
|
Ash |
08 %
maximum |
|
Calcium |
1.2% |
|
Phosphorus |
0.6 %
minimum |
|
NFE |
54 % |
|
ME
Kcal/Kg |
3600 |
|
Pallet
Size |
12 mm |
Acute toxicity study:
The acute toxicity study was performed to establish the therapeutic
index i.e. the ratio between the pharmacological effective dose and the lethal
dose to perform preliminary screening. The acute oral toxicity study was
carried out as per OECD guidelines 425, where doses of extract of plant
materials ranging from 175-2000 mg/kg were administered to animals 13.
Healthy female Wistar
rats weighing between 120-150 g maintained under standard laboratory conditions
were used for the acute toxicity test according to the Organization for
Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) guidelines 425. A total of five
female rats were used and each received a single oral dose of 2000 mg kg-1
body weight of ethanolic extract of C. nurvala
stem bark. Animals were kept overnight fasting prior to drug administration by
oral gavage. After administration of drug sample,
food was withheld for further 3-4 h. Animals were observed individually at
least once during first 30 min after dosing, periodically during first 24 h
(with special attention during the first 4 h) and daily thereafter for a period
of 14 days. Daily observations on the changes in skin and fur, eyes and mucus
membrane (nasal), respiratory rate, circulatory signs (heart rate and blood
pressure), autonomic effects (salivation, lacrimation,
perspiration, piloerection, urinary incontinence and
defecation), central nervous system (ptosis,
drowsiness, gait, tremors and convulsion) changes, body weight changes, cage
side parameters and mortality rate were noted (OECD, 2002) 14. The study protocol is summarized in table 2
Experimental design:
Twenty healthy female Wistar rats were used
for sub-chronic toxicity study. They were divided into four groups of five rats
each. Group I served as control and was fed with standard diet and water only.
Group II was fed with standard diet, water and 175 mg/kg of extract, while
Group III was fed with standard feed, water and 550 mg/kg of extract and Group
IV was fed with standard feed, water and 1750 mg/kg of extract of C. nurvala stem
bark (Table 3). The drugs were administered using a curved, ball-tipped
stainless steel feeding needle for a period of 14 days 15.
Table 2: Study
protocol for acute toxicity study
|
Name of the study |
Acute toxicity study |
|
Test material |
Ethanolic extract of stem
bark of C. nurvala |
|
Physical status of test material |
Semisolid extract |
|
Species/strain used |
Wistar rat |
|
Animal procured from |
Institutional animal house, NGSM Institute of Pharmaceutical Sciences |
|
Sex |
Female |
|
Weight range |
120-150 g |
|
Age |
8-12 weeks |
|
Route of administration |
Oral with help of gavage with stomach tube,
volume: 1 ml/dose |
|
Vehicle |
Distilled water |
|
No. of administration |
Single |
|
Concentration of doses |
2000 and 175, 550, 1750 mg/kg body weight |
|
Study duration |
14 days |
|
Parameters observed |
Cage side observation, body weight and mortality rate |
|
Housing condition |
Air conditioned room with 10-15 air changes per hour temperature
between 190-250 C, relative humidity 30-70%, and illumination cycle set to 12
hours light and 12 hours dark |
|
Accommodation |
Individual animals of similar sex in polypropylene cages with
stainless steel grill tops, facilities for food and water bottle, and bedding
of clean husk |
Table 3: Feeding study
|
Group |
Treatment |
Duration (days) |
No. of animals |
|
Group I (Control group) |
Normal feed + water |
14 |
5 |
|
Group II |
Feed +175 mg/kg bwt C. nurvala ethanolic
extract |
14 |
5 |
|
Group III |
Feed + 550 mg/kg bwt C. nurvala ethanolic
extract |
14 |
5 |
|
Group IV |
Feed +1750 mg/kg bwt C. nurvala ethanolic
extract |
14 |
5 |
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION:
Cage side observations:
Cage side observations
were reported by recording general observations of each animal on a daily basis
from the stage of dosing to the end of the study. Any changes or abnormalities
recorded could be an indication of toxicity. The test animals at all dose
levels of the extract showed no significant changes in behavior. The
observations for all parameters studied are summarized in Table 4.
Mortality rate:
Mortality is the main criteria in assessing
the acute toxicity study (LD50) of any drug. There was no mortality
recorded even at the highest dose level i.e. 2000 mg/kg body weight of the
plant extract.
Body weight changes:
Body weight changes are an important factor
to monitor the health of an animal. Loss of body weight is frequently the first
condition of the onset of adverse effects. A dose, which causes 10% or more
alteration in body weight, is considered to be toxic dose. All the animals from
treated groups did not show any significant alteration in body weight for 14
days. Moreover, there was no significant change in food and water intake of the
rest animals at all dose levels of the extract of C. nurvala stem bark.
Table4: Effect of ethanolic extract of C.
nurvala on acute oral toxicity test in Wistar rats
|
Parameters |
Observation |
|
Condition of the fur |
Normal |
|
Skin |
Normal |
|
Sub-cutenous swelling |
Nil |
|
Abdominal distension |
Nil |
|
Eye-dullness |
Nil |
|
Eye-opacities |
Nil |
|
Pupil diameter |
Normal |
|
Ptosis |
Nil |
|
Colour and consistency of
the faces |
Normal |
|
Condition of teeth |
Normal |
|
Breathing
abnormalities |
Nil |
|
Gait |
Normal |
CONCLUSION:
The non-toxic nature
of the ethanolic extract of C. nurvala stem bark is evident from the
acute oral toxicity conducted as per OECD 425 guidelines. The normal behavior
of the test animals during a period of 14 days suggests the non-toxic nature of
the foresaid extracts. Moreover, there were no significant changes in body
weight observed and mortality rate even at highest dose (2000 mg/kg body
weight) was found to be nil. Hence, C. nurvala could be safe up to the dose of 2000 mg/kg body
weight of the animal. Further studies are required for determining chronic
toxic symptoms.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS:
The authors
acknowledge the financial support of NGSM Institute of Pharmaceutical Sciences
and Nitte University, Mangalore, India for the
research work (Grant no. NU/PhD/Pharm/Res-10/2011).
REFERENCES:
1.
Ramila M and Manoharan
A. Characteristics of pharmacognostical significance
of Erythrina variegate var. and Ficus racemosa Linn. bark.
Journal of Chemical and Pharmaceutical Research. 3(6); 2011: 707-14.
2.
Muraleedharannair JM et al. Phytochemical
studies on Azolla pinnata R.
Br., Marsilea minuta L. and
Salvinia molesta
Mitch. Asian Pacific Journal of Tropical Biomedicine. 2; 2011: S26-29.
3.
Alam MB et al. In vitro and in vivo
antioxidant and toxicity evaluation of different fractions of Oxalis corniculata
linn. Journal of Pharmacology and Toxicology. 6; 2011: 337-48.
4.
Hazel BM, George WL and Kenneth DF. Medicinal herbs in
the United States: research Needs. Environmental Health Perspective. 107; 1999:
773-8.
5.
Angell M and Kassierr JP.
Alternative medicine – the risk of untested and unregulated remedies. The New
England Journal of Medicine. 339; 1998:
839-41.
6.
Patil AG et al. Pharmacognostical
standardization and HPTLC fingerprint of Crataeva tapia Linn. SSP. Orora
(Jacob.) almedia leaves. International Journal of
Pharmaceutical and Bio Science. 1(2); 2010: 1-14.
7.
Soosamma J et al. Phytochemistry
and pharmacology of an important Indian medicinal plant Crataeva nurvala Buch
Ham. Research Journal of Pharmacognosy and Phytochemistry. 2(4); 2010: 275-80.
8.
Rajesh K et al. Evaluation of antibacterial and anthelmintic activity of root extract of Crataeva nurvala. Pharmacologyonline. 1; 2011: 617-22.
9.
Udaysing HP. Differential bactericidal
potential and phytochemical evaluation of Crataeva religosa stem
bark. International Journal of Pharma Research and
Development. 2(1); 2011: 82-88.
10.
Farjana K et al. Evaluation of analgesic and antidiarrhoeal property of the ethanolic
extract of Crataeva nurvala Buch. Ham (Capparidaceae) leaves.
International Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences Review and Research. 12(2);
2012: 5-8.
11.
Latifou L et al. Antimicrobial activity of Crataeva religosa Forst against bacteria isolated form
Thryonomys swinderianus Termminck. African Journal of Biotechnology. 10(49); 2011:
1034-39.
12.
Shirish SP and Shrikant
SS. Acute toxicity study of Phyllanthus amarus. International Journal of Pharmaceutical
Sciences Review and Research. 9(1); 2011: 81-4.
13.
Sourabh SB et al. Acute Toxicity Study of
Aqueous Extract of Coccinia indica
(Roots). Asian Journal of Research in Pharmaceutical Sciences. 1(1); 2011:
23-25.
14.
Shirish SP. Acute toxicity study for Tinospora cordifolia.
International Journal of Research in Ayurveda and
Pharmacy. 2(5); 2011: 1571-73.
15.
Patrick-Iwuanyanwu KC et al.
Evaluation of acute and sub-chronic oral toxicity study of baker cleansers
bitters - a polyherbal drug on experimental rats. Excli Journal. 11; 2012: 632-40.
Received on 09.10.2013
Modified on 30.10.2013
Accepted on 05.11.2013
© A&V Publication
all right reserved
Research
Journal of Pharmacognosy and Phytochemistry. 5(6): November
–December 2013, 293-296